Try your own assumptions
Roth conversion calculator
What changes if you convert part of your IRA now? Compare the future after-tax value of two paths, including the savings you would use to pay the conversion tax.
For fully pretax IRA money, with the tax paid from outside savings. No email required. Calculations run in your browser.
Future Roth value. Assumes the full withdrawal qualifies for tax-free treatment.
after-tax IRA + outside savings.
Where the paths break even
This is a future wealth comparison, not a lifetime tax-savings estimate or a recommendation to convert.
Ask about a Roth conversionHow this works and what it leaves out
- Both paths start with the same pretax IRA amount and the same outside savings. The conversion uses those savings to pay the estimated tax. Keeping the IRA leaves them invested at your after-tax savings return.
- Future Roth value = conversion amount × (1 + retirement return)years. Keeping the IRA = that future value × (1 − future tax rate), plus the future value of the outside savings. All rates are entered as percentages.
- All selected IRA money is assumed to be pretax. This does not calculate tax brackets, nondeductible basis, a multiyear conversion schedule, or the tax effect on your other income.
- The entire selected IRA portion is valued after tax at the end of the period. No required minimum distributions, interim withdrawals, new contributions, Medicare surcharges, health-insurance subsidies, estate effects or inflation are modeled.
- Returns and tax rates stay constant in each illustration. Tax-rate estimates can include state taxes but do not automatically apply New York exclusions. Roth withdrawals must meet applicable age and holding-period rules; an early withdrawal may not qualify.
- Confirm conversion eligibility and tax assumptions with your tax professional. See IRS Publication 590-B for distribution and Roth withdrawal rules.
Compare the years before choosing the amount.
A Roth conversion moves eligible retirement money into a Roth IRA. The taxable portion generally adds to income in the conversion year.
Paying that tax is a tradeoff: future qualified Roth withdrawals can be tax-free, but the upfront cost may outweigh the benefit.
- Before retirement: wages, bonuses or a business sale may already make it a high-income year.
- After paychecks stop: there may be room before Social Security, a pension or required withdrawals begin. Check actual dates and spending needs.
- Later retirement: required distributions, survivor income and money intended for heirs can change the comparison. The lowest tax bill this year is only one part of it.
Start with your retirement income plan. If a business sale is the trigger, use the separate post-sale Roth conversion guide; sale proceeds and deal timing need their own analysis.
One large conversion or smaller steps?
| Approach | Added income | Illustrative tax |
|---|---|---|
| Convert in one year | $120,000 in year 1 | $32,800 |
| Spread over three years | $40,000 a year | $26,400 |
| Keep the IRA unchanged | $0 | $0 now; withdrawals taxed later |
Same $120,000, and a $6,400 difference in this example, because the one-year conversion pushes $80,000 into the higher rate. That is the idea behind spreading: fill the lower rate each year, then stop. It only works if the later years really are lower-income years. If a pension, Social Security or required withdrawals begin in year two, the room may be gone. Keeping the IRA unchanged preserves cash today and leaves future taxable withdrawals to plan for.
The next calculation is the incremental household cost of each approach: projected taxes with and without the conversion, possible changes to health-insurance costs, and the effect of using savings to pay the bill. Compare future after-tax spending under several assumptions. Spreading the same amount over three years does not, by itself, prove a saving.
Four checks before you convert.
- The taxable amount. Nondeductible IRA contributions can affect the calculation. Gather prior Forms 8606 and all relevant IRA balances; the treatment is not determined solely by the account selected for the transfer.
- Medicare. Higher income can increase Part B and Part D premiums. Social Security generally uses tax information from two years before the premium year, so a conversion can have a later cost.
- New York tax. New York taxes conversion income. If you are 59½ or older when you convert, the state’s pension and annuity exclusion can cover up to $20,000 of it per person each year. Taxable pension and other IRA income count against the same $20,000, so ask your CPA how much is left before you size the conversion. Other states have their own rules.
- Cash and timing. Identify how the tax will be paid without disrupting spending reserves. Check withholding or estimated-payment needs and the custodian’s processing deadline. Money withheld from a distribution is not money converted.
For someone under 59½, money taken out and not converted can also raise early-distribution tax questions. Roth withdrawal rules have separate age and holding-period requirements. A conversion should not leave you short of accessible money.
Sometimes the useful answer is to wait.
A conversion can be unattractive when the current tax cost is high, the household expects lower-tax withdrawals later, or paying the tax would weaken cash reserves.
Charitable plans, a possible move and an uncertain retirement date may also change the decision. Test a smaller conversion and no conversion alongside the proposed amount.
Bring the facts that change the answer.
- Your latest tax return and any Forms 8606 showing nondeductible IRA contributions.
- Current retirement-account balances and the years you expect wages, pensions and Social Security to begin or end.
- Expected household spending, available cash and any large gains or other one-time income.
- Any required distribution, charitable-giving plan, Medicare coverage or planned change of state residence.
How Morrowgate handles this. Morrowgate connects the conversion question to your retirement income and investment plan. Greg Garone, CEPA®, coordinates the assumptions and timing with your CPA. A planning engagement can compare conversion amounts and years, identify information still needed, and set out the next decisions. Scope and fees are agreed before work begins. See how fees and fit work.
Questions about Roth conversions
Does a Roth conversion always lower lifetime taxes?
No. The result depends on the tax paid now, future withdrawals, investment outcomes, time horizon and other household costs. Compare a conversion with leaving the money in the existing account.
Can I undo a conversion if my tax bill is larger than expected?
A Roth conversion made in 2018 or later cannot be reversed through recharacterization. Check the amount and tax-payment plan before processing it.
Can I convert my required minimum distribution?
No. An amount required to be distributed for the year is not eligible for conversion. Your custodian and tax professional should confirm the distribution and any separate conversion.
How much should I convert each year?
There is no standard amount. A common approach is to convert only enough to fill the tax bracket you are already in, and to stop short of the income levels that raise Medicare premiums. The figure changes each year with your income, so many people set it late in the year, once the numbers are known.
What is the five-year rule for Roth conversions?
Each conversion starts its own five-year clock. If you are under 59½ and take converted money out within those five years, a 10% early-withdrawal tax can apply. A separate five-year rule, counted from your first Roth IRA contribution or conversion, decides when earnings can come out tax-free. IRS Publication 590-B covers both.
Is this only for business owners?
No. This page is for retirees and people approaching retirement across Rochester and Western New York. Business sellers have additional timing questions covered in our separate post-sale guide.
How do I get started?
Ask about your retirement date, accounts and the decision you are weighing. We first establish fit and the scope of any paid work. Use the website for a general question; arrange a secure way to share documents afterward.
What this page is, and what it isn’t.
This is general education, not an individual conversion recommendation or a tax calculation. Examples are hypothetical. Your CPA confirms the tax treatment; your account provider confirms eligibility and processing. Rules and household circumstances can change.
Sources
- IRS: IRA distributions and Roth withdrawal rules (Publication 590-B)
- IRS: Form 8606 instructions and conversion reporting
- IRS: IRA questions, including conversion recharacterization
- Social Security: income used for Medicare premium adjustments
- New York: information for retired persons
- New York: Roth IRA conversion income and the $20,000 exclusion (TSB-M-98(7)I)
- IRS: converting a traditional IRA and required distributions (Publication 17)